Original mysteryNo. 3355 minHercule Poirot
Summoned to the Old Bailey to sit on a Special Jury, the Belgian Detective enters a trial that appears simple—a quarrel overheard, a father dead, a son arrested with a bloodied knife—yet inside the solemn woodwork and ticking clocks, certainty fractures as voices through walls, missing keys, and disputed timing complicate what the courtroom wants to call “obvious”; as twelve jurors divide between swift judgment and disciplined caution, the case becomes a battle between conscience and momentum, where the true stakes are not pride but a life that cannot be returned once taken; The Jury of Doubt is an original Golden Age–style mystery about persuasion, procedure, and the moral weight of deciding what “proof” really means. FOR LISTENERS This is an original Golden Age–style mystery presented as a respectful homage to classic detective fiction. All characters and events in this story are fictional. No affiliation, endorsement, or official connection is implied. QUESTION FOR THE COMMENTS If you believe someone is probably guilty, is it ever right to vote “not proven” in your own mind—because the proof is not strong enough? SUPPORT & LISTENING OPTIONS Patreon (ad-free episodes, early access, bonus content – tiers from $2.99/month) Buy Me a Coffee (one-time support) PayPal (one-time tip) Spotify (follow the show) CHILDREN’S BOOK (Amazon) Sherlock Paws and the Diamond of the Nile CREDITS Written by Nocturnal Tales. Narrated by Nocturnal Tales. TAGS / KEYWORDS golden age mystery audiobook, courtroom mystery drama, old bailey trial fiction, jury room suspense, london legal thriller, reasonable doubt theme, special jury case, knife evidence mystery, disputed timeline investigation, witness testimony puzzle, procedural justice story, psychological persuasion drama, classic detective fiction audio, moral dilemma mystery, full-length mystery audiobook
Free to listen, in full, with no account and no password. Your place is remembered in this browser, so you can stop and come back.
Every story on Nocturnal Tales is free, and stays free. Listeners who choose to give are the reason there is a new one tomorrow.
This is our work and what we live on: two of us, writing and producing a story every night. Giving here goes straight to us, rather than through a platform that can change its mind overnight. Why donations are important.
or
Give with PayPalPayPal opens in a new page. Monthly support is easiest to manage through the card option.
No story is ever locked. Payment is handled securely by Stripe — we never see your card details. You can change or cancel your support at any time, from this page, with no explanation needed.
Tell us what you made of this one. No account and no password — just a name.
Hercule Poirot
New Orleans, the spring of nineteen thirty-three. There are certain cities which, even before one has committed a crime in them, seem already to know the secret. Arthur and the Belgian Detective have come for a rest.
1 hr 14 minNo. 248
Max Carrados
It begins with Max Carrados greeting his friend Carlyle at the door and remarking that he has a mystery about him somewhere. He can hear it in the man's step. The mystery is a railway disaster.
by Ernest Bramah
1 hr 7 minNo. 247
A. J. Raffles
Two cases tonight from the gentleman thief who has drawn more requests than anybody else in the Archive. WILFUL MURDER is the darkest thing in the whole collection. Bunny warns us at the outset that most of their robberies will not bear telling at length.
by E. W. Hornung
1 hr 13 minNo. 246
Hercule Poirot
Mexico City, the summer of nineteen twenty-eight. A banquet is given for the man who is about to become President — a soldier who won a civil war, lost an arm doing it, and has spent the years since collecting enemies with the same efficiency he once collected territory.
1 hr 20 minNo. 245