Skip to the main content
Nocturnal TalesMystery audiobooks for quiet evenings

The Case of Oscar Brodski

by R. Austin Freeman

Classic mysteryNo. 2671 hr 52 minDr Thorndyke

Play this story
0:00
1:52:05

The story

A traveller in diamonds misses his train and calls at a house beside the line. That is all you need to know, because in a moment you are going to be told the rest. That is the point of it. This is the first inverted detective story ever written. Freeman shows you the crime — who, how, and every precaution taken — and only then brings in Dr John Thorndyke, so that you watch the science close on a man whose guilt you have never once doubted. The collection prints it in two halves and we keep them: The Mechanism of Crime, then The Mechanism of Detection. Every howcatchem since comes from this story, including a certain rumpled American lieutenant in a raincoat. Freeman wrote afterwards that he wanted to find out whether a detective story could survive having its secret given away at the start — whether the interest lay in the puzzle, or in the method. This is the experiment. At nearly two hours, it is also the longest thing we have run. Four of you asked for longer stories in the last ten days, none of you prompted. FOR LISTENERS This is a complete, unabridged reading of The Case of Oscar Brodski by R. Austin Freeman, collected in The Singing Bone (1912) and now in the public domain. Every word is the author's own. Part of The Midnight Archive: three nights of classics every week, alongside four original Nocturnal Tales mysteries. YOU CHOOSE WHAT'S NEXT The Archive is deep — more Dr Thorndyke? Max Carrados? Loveday Brooke? Judith Lee? Violet Strange? Sherlock Holmes? Father Brown? Lady Molly? Raffles? Arsène Lupin? Vote in the poll attached to this episode, or tell us in the comments which classic you want to hear by lamplight. You will know who did it from the first chapter. Did that make it more gripping or less — and was this the right length? CHAPTERS 00:00 - Introduction 01:57 - Part One - The Mechanism of Crime 20:18 - Part Two - The Mechanism of Crime 37:50 - Part Three - The Mechanism of Crime 55:59 - Part Four - The Mechanism of Detection 1:13:29 - Part Five - The Mechanism of Detection 1:32:16 - Part Six - The Mechanism of Detection 1:49:24 - Closing SUPPORT & LISTENING OPTIONS ABOUT THIS RECORDING The Case of Oscar Brodski by R. Austin Freeman (1912) is in the public domain. This recording is the complete, unabridged original text. Narration and production Nocturnal Tales. CREDITS Narrated and produced by Nocturnal Tales. Story by R. Austin Freeman (public domain). TAGS / KEYWORDS r austin freeman audiobook, dr thorndyke audiobook, the case of oscar brodski audiobook, the singing bone 1912, inverted detective story, first howcatchem story, forensic detective fiction, scientific detective story, long full length audiobook, classic detective story audiobook, public domain audiobook, unabridged classic mystery HASHTAGS

Free to listen, in full, with no account and no password. Your place is remembered in this browser, so you can stop and come back.

Enjoyed this one?

Every story on Nocturnal Tales is free, and stays free. Listeners who choose to give are the reason there is a new one tomorrow.

This is our work and what we live on: two of us, writing and producing a story every night. Giving here goes straight to us, rather than through a platform that can change its mind overnight. Why donations are important.

Choose a monthly amount

or

Give with PayPal

PayPal opens in a new page. Monthly support is easiest to manage through the card option.

No story is ever locked. Payment is handled securely by Stripe — we never see your card details. You can change or cancel your support at any time, from this page, with no explanation needed.

Be the first to comment

Tell us what you made of this one. No account and no password — just a name.

No account, no password. Your email is never shown to anyone, and is used only to reply to you unless you ask for the monthly note above.

More from the library

Cover illustration for A Most Unfortunate Rehearsal

A Most Unfortunate Rehearsal

Captain Hastings & Anne Foster

Dublin, the end of November 1929. Wet streets, a drawing room in Merrion Square, and Lady Eleanor, who would like it clearly understood that she never recommended the Captain as an actor.

2 hr 31 minNo. 299

Cover illustration for The Princess of Nowhere

Gloucestershire, the summer of 1926. A telegram arrives on an oppressive Thursday afternoon: Come immediately. A matter of the greatest delicacy. I fear we have welcomed something dreadful into our house.

1 hr 17 minNo. 298

Cover illustration for Arsène Lupin: The Jewish Lamp

A long evening with Arsène Lupin, the gentleman thief — and a duel. In this story Lupin meets the great English detective Herlock Sholmes and his friend Wilson, the names Maurice Leblanc gave to a certain famous pair from Baker Street.

by Maurice Leblanc

2 hrNo. 297